$50 million Starbucks lawsuit: A Los Angeles jury has awarded $50 million to delivery driver Michael Garcia, who sustained severe burns from a spilled Starbucks tea at a California drive-through in 2020. The incident, which occurred on February 8, left Garcia with permanent genital injuries requiring skin grafts and lifelong medical care, according to court documents.
$50 million starbucks lawsuit
The jury ruled on Friday that Starbucks’ negligence contributed to the accident, citing improper securing of the scalding-hot venti-sized tea in a takeout tray. Garcia’s legal team argued the company failed to enforce adequate safety protocols, leading to the life-altering injury.
Starbucks Responds
In a statement, the Seattle-based coffee chain expressed sympathy for Garcia but contested the verdict: “While we deeply regret this incident, we believe the jury’s decision misattributes fault and the awarded damages are disproportionate. We remain committed to stringent safety practices in preparing and serving beverages and will appeal the ruling.”
Legal Accountability Highlighted
Garcia’s attorney, Nick Rowley, hailed the decision as a victory for consumer safety: “This verdict underscores corporate responsibility. Starbucks’ refusal to acknowledge their lapse in safety standards necessitated this legal action to ensure accountability.”
Historical Context of Hot Beverage Lawsuits
The case echoes past litigation against food chains over burn injuries. Notably, a 1990s lawsuit against McDonald’s resulted in a $3 million award (later reduced) for a woman scalded by spilled coffee. However, courts have occasionally sided with businesses, such as in a 1990s Iowa case where a child’s coffee spill did not lead to liability.
The Garcia verdict reignites debates over corporate liability and safety measures in the food service industry. Starbucks’ appeal process is expected to unfold in the coming months.